How to Avoid the Most Common MIG/MAG Welding Defects

L'ABC du soudage

How to Avoid the Most Common MIG/MAG Welding Defects

15 février 2021

The quality requirements in welding production increase with the optimization of structures as well as the development of materials and welding processes. Welding defects can, at worst, cause serious accidents and structural damage, so it is important to avoid them and understand the mechanisms that create them. In this text, we present the most common MIG/MAG welding defects and the ways to best avoid them.

Reetta Verho

Welding quality assurance is a holistic job. High-quality welding operations are guaranteed by professional personnel, welding procedure specifications (WPS) and work instructions, and inspection activities. All areas must be in good condition for high-quality welds to emerge.

In the Finnish welding terminology standard SFS 3052, a welding defect is defined as “a discontinuity in the weld or deviation in the form of a weld. Welding defects include cracks, lack of penetration, porosity, and slag inclusion.” Moreover, the international standard ISO 6520-1 classifying and describing weld imperfections states a welding defect being “a discontinuity in the weld or deviation from the assumed geometry of the weld.”

What are the most common MIG/MAG welding defects?

The most common welding defects in MIG/MAG welding include e.g. porosity, inclusions, undercut, excessive asymmetry of fillet welds, lack of penetration, and spatters. Perhaps the most typical ones with the MIG/MAG welding process are spatters and lack of fusion. Each welding defect has its own reasons of origin that the welder must know in order to be able to avoid their creation.

Below are a few examples of typical MIG/MAG welding defects and how to prevent them from happening.

Lack of fusion

Reasons

Prevention method

Too narrow joint preparation

Ensure that the joint preparation is sufficiently wide

Incorrect gun angle

Make sure the gun angle will produce adequate side-wall fusion

Excessively high current or too low a welding speed, which creates weld pool flooding ahead of the arc, resulting in insufficient penetration

Select welding parameters (high welding current, short arc length, and not too high a welding speed) that promote sufficient penetration without causing flooding

Impurities on the joint faces

Clean the joint faces

‘Downhill welding’

Use vertical up welding

Too long arc / too high voltage

Use shorter arc / less voltage

Too low heat input

Increase heat input

Excessive fillet weld asymmetry

Reasons

Prevention method

Incorrect gun angle

Use the correct gun angles

Too large a weld pool

Reduce the deposition rate

Magnetic arc blow

Move the earth return clamp, use the shortest arc possible, reduce the welding current, angle the gun opposite the direction of arc blow, and/or use an AC power source

The welding defect limits are specified for each weld class in ISO 5817. In this standard, the limits are classified into three weld classes, namely grade B, C and D. In the mechanical engineering industry, the typical grade is grade C, but grade B is also often required in much more demanding welding production. The welding defects are presented in the standard as actual measurements. The detection and interpretation of these values ​​may require a destructive testing method alongside visual inspection.

Avoid welding defects to improve welding quality

Welding defects should be avoided simply because they require repair. All welding-related repair work in the production floor require time and therefore money. This will slow down production progress, and eventually delays in project schedules. However, the most unpleasant consequence of welding defects can at worst be a product or a structure breaking down, which can lead to various accidents and even personal injury.

We can detect welding defects by inspecting the welds, but at that time it is already late and the product has to be repaired. Welding production must be developed in the right direction in order to reduce the risk of welding defects. Such development measures may include, for example, tightening the quality requirements for groove preparation, changing the welding process, or changing the parameters. However, the training of welders is particularly important. The qualification of welders plays a very central role in quality improvement work.

Visual inspection and production monitoring in a key role

The most important method of welding inspection is visual inspection. Every welder should therefore also act as an inspector of their own work. Good results have been achieved in welding production when visual inspection training has been provided for welders. Often, even with such small measures, the quality of welds can be significantly improved.

Real-time production monitoring also plays a key role in preventing welding defects. Kemppi’s WeldEye software enables easy monitoring of welding production, as it automatically checks, for example, whether the welder is qualified for welding the product in question and that the qualification certificate has not expired. The software can also be used to monitor welding parameters and NDT inspections. At best, real-time monitoring of welding production can prevent welding defects from happening, and make it easier to find the cause of detected defects.

Reetta Verho
Author

Reetta Verho

Manager, Welding Services at Kemppi Oy. International Welding Engineer (IWE) who is an active member in ISO standardization committees. Board member in The Welding Society of Finland. Passionate about welding quality and the development of welding production. Member of: K105 National mirror committee for welding, ISO/TC44/SC10 Quality management in the field of welding ISO/TC44/SC11 Qualification requirements for welding and allied processes personnel.

Plus d'articles de blog

Calculation of heat input in MIG/MAG welding

Calculation of heat input in MIG/MAG welding

The new welding procedure test standard, EN-ISO 15614-1:2017, provides recommendations for the measurement and calculation of heat input. In concrete terms, what does this mean for MIG/MAG welding? And how can workshops carry out these calculations in practice?

L'ABC du soudage

Welding value with X5 FastMig

Welding value with X5 FastMig

Small improvements in welding efficiency can positively influence overall productivity and establish valuable cost savings. By investing in robust, reliable, and versatile equipment, you can improve and better manage welding project costs.

Soudage manuel

WeldEye enables remote work in welding production

WeldEye enables remote work in welding production

Managing welding production with a cloud-based software solution has considerable advantages. For one, it gives work supervisors or quality assurance teams the convenience of working remotely from home. It increases transparency, quality and efficiency, thanks to improved information flow and traceability. The welders also receive immediate feedback on their work.

Numérisation

How does steel welding benefit from special processes?

How does steel welding benefit from special processes?

Welding mild steels may often be considered a simple task. However, welding these steels has specific characteristics that can make the welding process challenging.

Soudage manuel, L'ABC du soudage

New Kemppi Robotics Team

New Kemppi Robotics Team

Achieving strategic goals and enhancing customer experience

Les personnes

Comment choisir sa torche de soudage MIG/MAG

Comment choisir sa torche de soudage MIG/MAG

Le soudage MIG/MAG est l'un des procédés de soudage les plus courants et les plus polyvalents. Il est utilisé pour diverses applications, telles que l'automobile, la construction, la fabrication et la maintenance. Cependant, il est essentiel de choisir une torche de soudage adaptée à votre travail pour obtenir des résultats optimaux.

Soudage manuel, L'ABC du soudage

Inscrivez-vous à notre newsletter et soyez parmi les premiers à découvrir les dernières actualités de Kemppi.

En vous abonnant, vous acceptez de recevoir des e-mails marketing de Kemppi.

Le précurseur du soudage à l'arc

Kemppi s’impose comme le leader en matière de conception dans l’industrie du soudage à l'arc. Grâce à l'optimisation continue de l'arc de soudage, nous nous engageons à améliorer la qualité et la productivité du soudage, tout en œuvrant pour un monde plus respectueux de l'environnement et plus équitable. Kemppi propose des produits durables, des solutions numériques et des services destinés aux professionnels, qu'il s'agisse de grandes entreprises industrielles ou d’entrepreneurs. La fiabilité et la simplicité d'utilisation de nos produits sont au cœur de notre philosophie. Fort d’un réseau de partenaires hautement qualifiés dans plus de 70 pays, nous rendons notre expertise accessible à l'échelle mondiale. Basée à Lahti, en Finlande, Kemppi compte plus de 650 professionnels dans 16 pays et a réalisé un chiffre d'affaires de 209 millions d'euros en 2023.

Kemppi – Designed for welders

Copyright © 2024 Kemppi Oy